- What changed
- NYC Council passed Intro 891-A, banning prices set by algorithms using a shopper's personal data
- When
- Passed November 12, 2026; not yet signed as of November 16; in force one year after it becomes law
- Who it affects
- Any business selling to NYC consumers, including out-of-state online sellers and their service providers
- What to do
- List every personalized price or discount you show NYC shoppers and move them to uniform, rule-based offers
Key takeaways
- NYC's Council passed a surveillance pricing ban 44 to 5 on November 12, 2026; it reaches out-of-state online sellers and takes effect a year after signing.
- Uniform discounts and market-based dynamic pricing stay legal; personalized abandoned cart codes may not, per the Council's own report.
- Fines reach $1,000 per violation, counted per consumer or transaction, so audit personalized offers now.
The road to surveillance pricing limits
NY State algorithm price label rule in force
Seattle signs a city ban
NYC Council passes Intro 891-A, 44 to 5
Deadline for Hochul on One Fair Price Act
Connecticut restrictions start
NYC ban enforceable
What the Council passed on November 12
Speaker Julie Menin's bill, Introduction 891-A, passed 44 to 5 on Thursday, November 12, 2026, City and State New York reported. Mayor Mamdani's office said it supports the bill, but Reclaim The Net reported on November 16 that he had not yet signed it. Once signed, it takes effect one year later.
The bill text, as quoted by Reclaim The Net, defines surveillance pricing as a price set completely or in part by an algorithm that uses personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the same goods. Personal data is anything that identifies, or could reasonably be linked to, a specific consumer or device. The bill also bans collecting, selling or keeping personal data to make that kind of pricing possible.
Who is covered, including sellers outside New York
Olshan's client alert says the law reaches any entity domiciled in New York City or transacting with consumers there, including out-of-state sellers. Its advice: online businesses selling to New York City shoppers should assume it applies wherever they are located. Blocking New York City by geofence may cut exposure for an out-of-state seller, but it does not help a business based in the city.
Enforcement sits with the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. Fines run up to $1,000 per violation, and each affected consumer or transaction counts separately. There is no private right of action. Small businesses get a chance to fix a first violation, described as a 30 day cure. Service providers, such as pricing software vendors, are only liable if they show reckless disregard of the law. Businesses that use personal data for pricing or custom discounts must keep procedures that explain what data they used and hand them to the city on request.
Shopify growth, SEO, email and paid social, connected to your marketplace strategy.
What stays legal, and the discount that may not
Dynamic pricing is not banned. Olshan notes that prices moved by demand, inventory, timing or competition remain allowed as long as everyone sees the same price at the same moment. That covers most Amazon repricers, which react to competitor offers rather than to who is shopping. Uniform discounts also stay legal: buy one get one, loyalty tiers, birthday offers, student and veteran discounts, flash sales, subscription deals, price matching and rebates, provided every shopper who meets the condition gets the same terms.
The surprise is abandoned cart offers. Olshan cites the Council's legislative report saying they may no longer be permitted. A code that appears only because a specific shopper browsed and left is built on that shopper's behaviour, which is exactly what the bill targets. Personalized pop ups, email discounts sized by predicted willingness to pay, and app prices that vary by device are in the same risk zone.
| Stays legal | At risk | |
|---|---|---|
| Price moves with demand or stock | ||
| Loyalty tiers and birthday offers | ||
| Same code for every email signup | ||
| Personal abandoned cart codes | ||
| Prices varied by device or profile |
Per Olshan Frome Wolosky and the Council's report
So what: this is bigger than one city
New York State already requires the label THIS PRICE WAS SET BY AN ALGORITHM USING YOUR PERSONAL DATA under its Algorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act, in force since November 10, 2025. The state One Fair Price Act, which would ban the practice statewide, has passed the Legislature and awaits Governor Kathy Hochul, who must act by December 31, 2026. Seattle signed a city ban in October, and Connecticut restrictions start July 1, 2027. Consumer Reports' Grace Gedye said companies may simply apply the rule nationwide. For a brand, that makes a one time cleanup of personalized pricing cheaper than running separate rules by city.
Worked example with illustrative numbers
These numbers are illustrative, not from any enforcement case. A Shopify brand sends 1,500 abandoned cart emails a month with a personalized 15% code, and 8% of its customers live in New York City. That is about 120 New York City shoppers a month receiving an offer the Council's report flags. If each counted as one violation at the $1,000 maximum, monthly exposure would be up to $120,000, against perhaps $1,800 in recovered sales if 15 of those 120 shoppers buy a $120 order.
Switch to a uniform rule, such as 10% off for every shopper who signs up for email, and the same recovered revenue becomes defensible. The math rarely favours keeping the personalized version.
What sellers should do before the law takes effect
These steps fit a founder, ecommerce manager or email lead, and none require waiting for the mayor's signature.
- Ecommerce manager: list every app on your Shopify or website stack that changes price or discount by shopper, including pop ups, quiz offers and cart recovery tools. Metric: a written inventory with each tool marked uniform or personalized.
- Email lead: rewrite abandoned cart flows to offer the same published incentive to everyone, or no discount at all. Metric: recovered revenue per send holds within a few points of the old flow over 30 days.
- Amazon manager: confirm your repricer rules use competitor and stock signals only, which is how most Amazon dynamic pricing tools work. Metric: same price shown to every shopper at the same time.
- Founder: ask each pricing vendor in writing whether its model uses personal or device data, since vendors face their own liability bar. Metric: a signed answer on file.
- Legal or finance: keep a short document explaining what data, if any, feeds your prices and discounts, because the city can ask for it. Metric: document ready within a day of a request.
Pricing audit before 2027
- List every tool that changes price
- Mark each uniform or personalized
- Rewrite cart recovery flows
- Check repricer signals
- Get vendor answers in writing
- Keep a data use document
When this does not apply
If you sell only on Amazon and use Amazon's own coupons and deals, Amazon sets how those are shown, so your exposure is mainly through your own repricing rules and any off-Amazon store. Insurance, credit priced on consumer reports, broker dealers and prices required by federal or state law are exempt. B2B sellers that do not sell to consumers are outside a consumer protection law like this. And until the mayor signs and the year passes, nothing is enforceable in the city, though the state disclosure law already is.
How PPC Spider can help
PPC Spider manages Amazon and Shopify growth for brands, and we build pricing and promotion plans on uniform rules from the start. Read our Amazon pricing strategy and coupons and promotions guides, see our Shopify DTC agency work, follow the Shopify and ecommerce news channel, or ask for a free Amazon audit.
Sources
- New York City Council: Council to vote on surveillance pricing ban, November 12, 2026 (https://council.nyc.gov/press/2026/11/12/3336/)
- City and State New York: Julie Menin's surveillance pricing ban passes the Council (https://www.cityandstateny.com/policy/2026/11/julie-menins-surveillance-pricing-ban-passes-council/417196/)
- Olshan Frome Wolosky: NYC Council passes ban on surveillance pricing, and online sellers nationwide should take note (https://www.olshanlaw.com/newsroom/alerts/client-alert-nyc-council-passes-ban-on-surveillance-pricing-and-online-sellers-nationwide-should-take-note)
- Reclaim The Net: NYC Council votes 44 to 5 to ban surveillance pricing (https://reclaimthenet.org/nyc-council-votes-44-5-to-ban-surveillance-pricing)
We run these playbooks on client accounts every day. Start with a free audit.
Get a free audit