What changed
Amazon in-app campaign against NYC Intro 518, which would end its contracted last-mile delivery model in the city
When
Pop-ups went live November 19, 2026; the bill awaits review by Council Speaker Julie Menin
Who it affects
Amazon, NYC Council, Mayor Mamdani, Amazon delivery partners, and brands that ship FBA orders to NYC
What to do
Measure your NYC order share and watch delivery promises on NYC ZIP codes

Key takeaways

  • On November 19, 2026 Amazon told NYC app users Intro 518 could add up to $5 per order and said it might consider moving delivery out of the city.
  • The bill would require licensing and direct employment of last-mile drivers; Speaker Menin is reviewing it and calls Amazon's claim deceptive.
  • Nothing changes for FBA fees today; measure NYC order share and delivery promises now so you have a baseline.

Amazon and NYC Intro 518

  1. Amazon starts its contracted delivery partner model

  2. Intro 518 introduced by Tiffany Caban

  3. Mayor Mamdani endorses the bill

  4. Amazon app pop-ups warn of up to $5 per order

  5. Amazon says 60,000+ emails sent to council

  6. Speaker Menin review; amendments possible

What Amazon told New York shoppers on November 19

Starting Thursday, November 19, people who opened the Amazon app in New York City saw a pop-up saying the Council could add up to $5 per order if it passes Intro 518. A fixed banner on the homepage links to a form that sends an email to the shopper's council member asking them to oppose the bill, CNBC and NBC New York reported.

Amazon says the bill would stop it from working with the more than 40 small delivery businesses it uses in the city and the 5,000-plus New Yorkers they employ. Its message says it could be forced to consider moving operations outside the city, which it says would mean slower and more expensive delivery for millions of customers. Amazon said 20,000 customers emailed council members in the first six hours, and more than 60,000 emails had gone out by Friday, November 20. Those counts are Amazon's own.

None of the reports we read explain how Amazon arrived at the $5 figure, and Amazon's wording is hedged: up to $5, and might consider moving.

What Intro 518 would actually change

The bill, sponsored by Councilmember Tiffany Caban and introduced in February, would require operators of last-mile delivery facilities to be licensed by the city and to employ delivery workers directly instead of through contractors, Reuters reported. That would end the Delivery Service Partner model Amazon has used since 2018, in which small companies employ the drivers who carry Amazon packages.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani endorsed the bill in August, and NBC New York reports it has support from a supermajority of council members. Speaker Julie Menin, who has the bill under review, told CNBC that the price claim defies logic and said the Council is writing legislation that regulates Amazon without hurting prices or jobs. CBS New York reports she is open to changes, possibly licensing warehouse operations instead of banning third-party delivery. The Teamsters back the bill; delivery business owners and business groups have warned they may sue if it passes as written.

So what: why a city bill reaches a brand's P&L

Amazon's FBA fulfillment fees are set nationally, so nothing in this fight changes your fee card today. The exposure is speed and price for NYC shoppers. New York City is one of the densest delivery markets in the country, and same-day and next-day promises there depend on the local delivery partner network Amazon says the bill would break up. If delivery moves to facilities outside the city, promise times on NYC ZIP codes could lengthen, and shorter promises are part of why shoppers convert.

The second risk is price. If Amazon ever passed even part of a $5 per order cost to shoppers, a $25 basket would cost 20% more to deliver in the city, and low-priced add-on items would feel it first. Nothing has been decided: the bill can still be amended, delayed or challenged in court. Track it the way you would a fee change, with dates and a plan, not panic. Our Amazon FBA news channel will update this story as the Council acts.

Worked example: a brand with 4% of orders in NYC

Illustrative numbers only. Say a supplement brand ships 12,000 FBA orders a month at a $28 average order value, and 4% of orders, 480 a month, go to the five boroughs. If delivery promises in the city slip from next day to three days and conversion on those shoppers falls 10%, the brand loses about 48 orders, or $1,344 in monthly sales, before any price change.

If shoppers were also asked to pay more per order, the loss could be larger on single-item baskets. The same brand selling a $12 refill would be the most exposed, since a delivery cost of a few dollars is a large share of that price. A brand whose NYC share is under 1% can treat this as a watch item.

What sellers should do now

Do these before Black Friday on November 27, while delivery promises are still normal and you have a clean baseline.

  • Analyst: pull the All Orders report in Seller Central and count orders by ship-postal-code for NYC ZIPs (100xx to 104xx and 111xx to 116xx). Metric: your NYC share of orders and revenue.
  • Brand manager: set your delivery location to a Manhattan and a Brooklyn ZIP and record the delivery promise on your top 10 ASINs each week. Metric: days to delivery shown on the product page.
  • Ops lead: keep at least 60 days of cover in FBA for your top sellers through January so any network change does not stack on a stockout, using our FBA inventory management guide. Metric: days of supply in the FBA Inventory page.
  • Finance: model a scenario where NYC conversion drops 10% and keep it in your Q1 plan. Metric: revenue at risk in dollars per month.
  • Founder: if NYC is a large share of revenue, compare a regional backup such as merchant fulfilled shipping from a New Jersey 3PL, using our FBA vs FBM comparison. Metric: landed cost per order by channel.

NYC delivery risk check for brands

  • NYC share of orders measured
  • Promise times logged for 2 NYC ZIPs
  • Top ASINs at 60+ days of FBA cover
  • 10% NYC conversion drop modeled
  • Backup FBM or 3PL option priced

When this does not apply

If you ship most orders yourself through UPS, FedEx or USPS, the bill does not target your carriers directly. If your NYC order share is small, the money at risk is small. And until the Council votes, nothing changes: Amazon's warning is a campaign message, not a fee notice.

Where PPC Spider helps

We track promise times, stock cover and conversion by ASIN so a regional delivery change shows up in the numbers before it shows up in the sales report. See our Amazon account management service, check fee math in our Amazon FBA fees guide, or start with a free Amazon audit.

Sources

Get the next change before your competitors do

We send the marketplace changes that matter each week, with what to do next.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.
Want this done for your account?

We run these playbooks on client accounts every day. Start with a free audit.

Get a free audit