What changed
Groundwork report: 29.1% of 350+ Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2024 and 2025 deals gave no savings vs the prior month, 9.4% cost more; Amazon says 98% were at or below the prior 30-day price
When
Report and Amazon rebuttal published November 16, 2026; Amazon letter to Groundwork dated November 13; Black Friday Week runs November 19 to 30
Who it affects
Amazon, Groundwork Collaborative, and every seller running Black Friday Week or Cyber Monday deals
What to do
Check each deal price against your lowest price in the prior 30 days and your strikethrough reference price before November 19

Key takeaways

  • Groundwork says 29.1% of 350+ Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals in 2024 and 2025 saved nothing vs the prior month; Amazon says 98% met its 30-day rule.
  • A deal badge needs a price at or below the prior 30-day low; strikethrough savings need a reference price validated over 90 to 180 days.
  • Check every Black Friday Week deal against your 30-day low, including coupons, before November 19.

Groundwork's findings vs Amazon's rebuttal

29.1%no saving vs prior 30 days
9.4%priced higher than prior month
27%higher than prior 90 days
98%at or below 30-day low (Amazon)
Source: Groundwork Collaborative; About Amazon, Nov 16, 2026

What the report says

Groundwork's report, titled Deal or Decoy? Amazon's Deceptive Discounts, examined the prices of more than 350 products listed on Amazon's own Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025. It found 29.1% were priced the same or higher during the sale than in the 30 days before it, and 9.4% were priced higher. Looking back 90 days instead of 30, the share with no savings rises to nearly 60%, and the share that cost more rises to 27%.

Among the deals that cost more, the median sale price was 19% above the recent low, the group says. Its examples include Hunter rain boots listed at $126.99 on Black Friday 2025 after selling for $79.97 nine days before the event, and UGG Butte boots at $179.98 on Cyber Monday 2025 after $98.40 about four weeks earlier. Groundwork asks federal and state regulators to require retailers to show the lowest price of the previous 30 days whenever they advertise a sale.

What Amazon says

Amazon's statement, posted on its company news site on November 16, says the sample is cherry picked: 350 products out of more than 10 million deals in those events, with only 17 of its top 200 best-selling deals included. It says the research used prices higher than what customers were offered, missed Early Event deals that start before an event and hold the same price through it, and counted products that never carried a deal badge, only a strikethrough reference price. Amazon also says Groundwork first studied about 1,500 products from Prime Day 2026 and Black Friday 2025, then dropped the 2026 data. Yahoo reports Groundwork said it removed Prime Day because that event is open only to Prime members.

Amazon's own count is that 98% of the products in the report were at or below their prior 30-day price, rising to 99% for 2025, and that it tightened event guardrails in 2026 so deals almost always carry the lowest price of the past 30 days. Groundwork told Yahoo it stands by its findings. Both sides are interested parties, and neither dataset has been published in full.

How the dispute unfolded

  1. Amazon letter to Groundwork disputes the data

  2. Report published; Amazon posts rebuttal

  3. Black Friday Week deals start

  4. Black Friday Week ends

The detail most coverage misses: two price rules, two windows

Amazon's rebuttal spells out the rules sellers are graded on. A deal badge needs a price at or below the lowest price of the prior 30 days. The savings shown must use a validated reference price, such as List Price, which Amazon confirms from prices paid on Amazon or offered by reputable retailers over the past 90 to 180 days, depending on category. A product can also show a strikethrough reference price without being a deal at all.

That gap is where the fight sits. A price can pass Amazon's 30-day test and still look like no saving against a 90-day low, which is the lens Groundwork used for its 60% figure. Shoppers can now check this themselves: Amazon says Alexa for Shopping shows up to 365 days of price history and more than 400 million customers used it in the last 12 months. Our guide to the Amazon fair pricing policy covers the separate rule on prices far above recent levels.

So what: the money and the risk

For a brand, a deal that fails the 30-day rule usually loses its badge and the event traffic that comes with it. A deal that passes but sits above a recent coupon or promotion price can still draw complaints, screenshots and review comments about fake savings, at the moment your listing gets the most traffic of the year. Groundwork's earlier pricing work on Instacart, it says, was followed by FTC and New York Attorney General inquiries, so this report may not be the last word.

Example with illustrative numbers. A $40 product ran a 20% coupon for one week in early November, so its lowest price in the prior 30 days is $32. The brand plans a Black Friday deal at $34, which looks like 15% off the $40 reference price. Under the rule Amazon describes, $34 is above the $32 low, so it should not earn a deal badge. To qualify, the deal must be $32 or less. On 500 event units, the difference between $34 and $32 is $1,000 of revenue, which is the real cost of the earlier coupon. Planning the coupon calendar around the event avoids that trade.

What sellers should do

Most fixes take an afternoon. Do them before deals go live on November 19.

  • Pricing owner: export the lowest price each deal ASIN sold at in the last 30 days, including coupons, Prime exclusive discounts and Lightning Deals, and confirm every Black Friday Week deal price is at or below it. Metric: zero planned deals priced above the 30-day low.
  • Pricing owner: freeze list price and base price changes on deal ASINs until Cyber Monday ends. Raising a price before an event is exactly the pattern the report describes. Metric: no price increases logged in the 30 days before the event.
  • Brand manager: in the Deals and Promotions pages of Seller Central, check that each submitted deal is still eligible after any recent coupon. Our guides to Amazon Lightning Deals and coupons and promotions explain how they stack. Metric: no deals suppressed on day one.
  • Catalog owner: check the strikethrough reference price on hero ASINs. If it no longer reflects what shoppers paid recently, expect it to drop off. Metric: reference price shown on every hero product page.
  • PPC manager: point event budgets only at ASINs with a live deal badge, and pause deal-led ad copy on any ASIN that loses it. Metric: event ACoS on badged ASINs vs unbadged.
  • Customer care: watch reviews and questions for fake deal complaints during the event and answer quickly. Metric: no new one-star reviews mentioning price.

Deal price check before November 19

  • Deal price at or below 30-day low
  • Coupons and Prime discounts counted
  • No price rises before the event
  • Reference price still shown
  • Deal still eligible after coupons
  • Ads point only at badged ASINs

When this does not apply

If you are not running event deals and sell at a steady price, nothing here changes for you. Sellers outside the US face different rules: the EU already requires a 30-day prior price on announced discounts. This report has no legal force and no regulator has announced action on it; it matters because it shapes press coverage and future rules, not because any seller's deals were found unlawful.

Where PPC Spider helps

Our Amazon PPC management team plans deal calendars and ad budgets together, and SpiderOS tracks prices, coupons and badges per ASIN. See the full Amazon Black Friday 2026 guide, more on the Amazon policy updates channel, or get a free Amazon audit of your Q4 pricing and deals.

Sources

Get the next change before your competitors do

We send the marketplace changes that matter each week, with what to do next.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.
Want this done for your account?

We run these playbooks on client accounts every day. Start with a free audit.

Get a free audit